Experiments in Biochar, Wood Pellets, small Scale

Erin Rasmussen



Method and results

Method: Top lit updraft (TLUD) pyrolysis in a small and simple selfmade stove. When the pyrolysis zone hits bottom and the big bright flame reduces to a small blue flame, then the stove is closed airtight with a lid and covered with a can and let cool down. Burn time ca. 35min. Batch size: 325g. Total pellet input: 2264g.

Resulting char:
* Ashes: negligible (mostly from lighting the stove)
* Pellet energy yield: 75%
* Volume reduction: ca. 50% (from visual inspection, To do: measurement from photo)
* Weight: 15%
* Water absorption: 125% of char weight (at ca. 16°C)
* Charred pellets don’t fall apart

"Energy yield": Alas my TLUD stove just gives nice light and is not useable for indoor heating. Modern pellet heating systems run at 85%-95% efficiency. According to the manufacturer, pellets give 5kWh/kg, being 18GJ/t. According to this wood has 18-22GJ/t and charcoal has 30GJ/t, i.e. 8.3kWh/kg. Alas I don’t have the lab to check this with my peculiar kind of charcoal. Energy yield computed as (5 - 0.15 * 8.3) / 5 = 0.751

Volume reduction is roughly in accordance with estimates in en.wikipedia Charcoal and de.wikipedia Holzkohle.

According to en.wikipedia, weight reduction should be 25%. The lower number is to be expected,

* from the characteristics of TLUD pyrolysis: "more of the bio-oil condensates are driven off" (loc. cit.).
* as wood pellets are made from saw dust, the wood pores are more accesible and volatile components easier driven off.

The higher porosity is reflected in the huge water absorption of 125% of char weight:

* Great benefit for use as soil additive
* Probably better control of long term recalcitrance, as the short term decaying matter is burned out. (See discussion on blog here)

Other than standard BBQ charcoal, my pellet charcoal needs not to be cooked to gain its full water holding capacity: A few days in cold water suffice. (To do: determine water holding capacity of BBQ char.)

for more detail see their web page:
http://www.azimuthproject.org/azimuth/show/Experiments+in+biochar#the_fossil_fools_cost_in_euro_per_ton_4

An application

The char pellets could be used for a simplified and superior construction of a bokashi compost bucket producing non-acidic seepage fluid: Instead of a grate separating material from seepage, use wood pellet char. They provide enough space for the seepage. Without char, the fluid has pH <4 and needs to be diluted 1:100 - 1:500 before use in garden. Whith char it is pH 6.5. (Tests running, 2nd filling still gives pH 6.5. Applied at 1:2, my indoor palm tree is still alive.)

The fossil fool’s cost in Euro per ton

Computing the cost of char per metric ton relative to heating oil, where 1kg pellets = 0.5l oil. German prices as of 5.Feb.2011, incl. 19% VAT. Oil price includes <10% “eco”tax, precise value irrelevant due to the large price fluctuations (cf. e.g. this chart).

* Wood pellets: 241€/t for a 3-12t order.
* Heating oil: 0.78€/l

1t char requires 1t / 0.15 = 6.67t pellets.
Pellet cost: 6.67t * 241€/t = 1607€

Energy yield as heating oil equivalent: 0.75 * 6670kg * 0.5l/kg = 2500l oil
Energy yield in oil price: 2500l * 0.78€/l = 1950€

Result: 1607€ - 1950€ = -343€/t (incl. VAT). In U.S.$ (VAT substracted, 1.36€/$) -378$/t

for more detail see their web page:
http://www.azimuthproject.org/azimuth/show/Experiments+in+biochar#the_fossil_fools_cost_in_euro_per_ton_4